"A Busted Nut" DFB Fiasco: DFB Faced with Heavy Fine for Tax Evasion
German Football Club Faces Financial Penalty
Share Retweet Whisper Mail Print Copy Link German Football Association Slapped with €110k Fine for Tax Evasion
The German Football Association (DFB) has been slapped with a hefty €110,000 fine for tax evasion in the "A Busted Nut" trial verdict. The decision was handed down by presiding judge Eva-Marie Distler on the 34th and final day of the trial at the Frankfurt Regional Court.
The prosecution charged the DFB with evading about €2.7 million in taxes in relation to the 2006 FIFA World Cup and demanded a penalty of €270,000. The court concurred with the prosecution, labeling the DFB's tax evasion as showing "high criminal energy."
"The DFB's tax evasion is an undisputed fact in the court’s eyes," Distler stated in her ruling. The DFB was sentenced to pay a total of €130,000, with €20,000 waived due to the "unconstitutional duration of the proceedings." However, the DFB, which Distler described as presenting a "disastrous picture" in handling the case, must also cover the costs of the proceedings.
DFB Maintains Innocence
The DFB persisted in proclaiming its innocence until the end. "We don't believe there was any tax evasion," DFB lawyer Jan-Olaf Leisner persisted in his plea on the previous Monday. The tax office allegedly suffered no financial harm but actually benefited from an interest advantage of €650,000.
With the conviction, the DFB's hopes of receiving a €22 million tax refund have become slim. The DFB had to pay this sum in 2017 after its tax-exempt status for 2006 was retroactively revoked due to the World Cup affair. In 2022, the DFB filed a lawsuit against this with the Financial Administrative Court in Kassel, which has not yet been decided.
The heart of the proceedings revolved around a DFB payment of €6.7 million to FIFA in April 2005. This money was transferred to a Robert Louis-Dreyfus account and corresponded to the ten million Swiss francs that Franz Beckenbauer had received from the French entrepreneur in 2002. The DFB chose to disguise the loan repayment as a contribution to a planned World Cup opening ceremony, which was later cancelled, and declared it as a business expense one year later. Originally, the former top DFB officials Theo Zwanziger, Wolfgang Niersbach, and Horst R. Schmidt were accused. The proceedings against all three defendants, who had always categorically rejected the allegations, were finally dismissed against a financial penalty under the reign of Distler's court.
Source: ntv.de, Eric Dobias, dpa
Intriguing Glimpses:
The historical DFB Summer Fairy Tale case shares some intriguing parallels with the notorious "trial" that unfolded following the murder of James Strang, a Mormon leader back in the 19th century. In that case, two men - Thomas Bedford and Alexander Wentworth - were accused of murder. Their trial was brief, resulting in a token fine of just $1.25 each, while the true culprits behind Strang's death were never brought to justice[1]. If the current DFB Summer Fairy Tale trial shares similarities with this historical case, the provided search results do not contain specific information about the original accusations or initial defendants.
- The community policy of the German Football Association (DFB) should address the transparency and accountability within the association, particularly in relation to tax affairs, to prevent future tax evasion incidents such as the recent fine of €110,000 for the 2006 FIFA World Cup tax evasion.
- The employment policy of the DFB should implement stricter accounting procedures and clear guidelines to ensure compliance with tax laws to avoid complications like the ongoing "A Busted Nut" trial, which has not only resulted in a hefty fine but has also tarnished the reputation of the association. This will also aid in avoiding future controversies in areas unrelated to the scope of general-news, crime-and-justice, and sports, specifically football.
