"Genesis' five-member lineup was always a recipe for creative disagreements, and their reunion for a film project proved no exception."
In 2014, Genesis, the iconic classic rock band, reunited for a documentary titled "Genesis: Together and Apart" (also known as "Sum Of The Parts"), which brought together the band's classic lineup, including Peter Gabriel, Phil Collins, and Steve Hackett. The reunion, however, was not without its controversies.
The documentary, while intended to explore the band's history and their solo careers, received criticism from fans and band members alike. Steve Hackett, for instance, felt that the documentary was biased and did not adequately represent his solo work. Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford, on the other hand, acknowledged the complexities and less-than-harmonious aspects of Genesis's history.
One of the key issues raised was the band's democratic structure. According to Rutherford, Genesis was a democracy in theory but not in practice. This was evident in their creative process, where the band's multiple writing ideas often led to tension and disagreements.
The band's history was also marked by periods of strife. Banks and Rutherford admitted that life in the band wasn't always harmonious. For instance, Banks was often seen as a problem due to his bolshy nature, while Gabriel was known for making himself look as pretty as possible during later periods of the band's career.
Despite these challenges, the band remained active in 2014, releasing a three-CD anthology called "R-Kive". The anthology included songs from the solo work of its classic line-up members. However, some fans viewed the tracklisting as overly safe, a reflection of the band's complex history and the tensions that have always existed within Genesis.
Interestingly, Genesis was initially perceived as po-faced, but their approach was more about "banging it around" and not cerebral. This misconception may have contributed to the band's struggles and the tensions that arose during their career.
In conclusion, the reunion for the documentary highlighted the enduring tensions and creative differences within the band, even during a non-musical collaboration. Despite these challenges, Genesis continues to be a significant part of rock music history, their music resonating with fans worldwide.
[1] Classic Rock, "Genesis: Together and Apart – interview with Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford", link [2] Classic Rock, "Genesis: Together and Apart – interview with Steve Hackett", link [3] Classic Rock, "Steve Hackett criticises Genesis documentary", link
- Genesis, the iconic classic rock band, faced criticism from fans and band members for the documentary "Genesis: Together and Apart", including Steve Hackett who felt it was biased towards the other members.
- Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford admitted to the complexities and less-than-harmonious aspects of Genesis's history, but acknowledged that they still remained active in 2014.
- The band's reunion documentary was initially intended to explore their history and solo careers, but the band members' creative differences and disputes were highlighted instead.
- In 2014, Genesis released a three-CD anthology called "R-Kive", featuring songs from the solo work of its classic line-up members, but some fans felt the tracklisting was overly safe, reflecting the band's complex history.
- The band's approach to music was originally misconstrued as po-faced, but it was more about "banging it around" and not cerebral, which may have contributed to the tensions that arose during their career.
- Steve Hackett, Phil Collins, and Peter Gabriel, the classic lineup of Genesis, came together for the documentary "Genesis: Together and Apart", but the reunion was marked by controversies surrounding the representation of each member's solo work.
- The documentary, "Genesis: Together and Apart," had interviews with Tony Banks, Mike Rutherford, and Steve Hackett, providing insight into their perspectives on the band's history and the creative tensions that existed.
- Despite the enduring tensions and creative differences within the band, Genesis continues to be a significant part of rock music history, their music resonating with fans worldwide.
