Former Sinn Fein leader Gerry Adams victorious in libel lawsuit against BBC; Jury rules BBC failed to act honestly, awarding Adams €100,000 ($113,000) in compensation.
Sinn Fein's former leader, Gerry Adams, has won a libel lawsuit against the BBC, following accusations that he approved the killing of an informant within the Irish republican movement.
On Friday, a Dublin High Court jury ruled in favor of Adams, determining that the BBC had not acted in good faith and had not demonstrated fair and reasonable journalistic practices. The verdict awarded Adams €100,000 in damages.
The dispute stemmed from a 2016 BBC Spotlight documentary and an accompanying online article that alleged Adams had authorized the murder of Denis Donaldson, a long-time Sinn Fein official who publicly admitted to working for British intelligence. Donaldson was found dead at his Irish cottage four months later.
The BBC Spotlight investigation included claims from an anonymous source suggesting that the IRA's political and military leadership, including Adams, had sanctioned Donaldson's killing. The alleged report also stated that Adams had given the final say on the matter.
Speaking to reporters outside the court after the verdict, Adams, aged 76, said his case reflected a need to impose courtesy on the British Broadcasting Corporation. Adams' legal representatives expressed their satisfaction with the resounding decision.
Adams, a significant player in Northern Ireland's decades-long conflict and the peace process, served as Sinn Fein's leader from 1983 to 2018. Although he has consistently denied being an IRA member, former associates have claimed that he held a leadership position within the organization.
Following the court ruling, the BBC expressed disappointment with the verdict and emphasized the thorough editorial process and journalistic diligence applied to the program and associated online article. They asserted that the article and documentary were of utmost public interest, provided extensive evidence in support of their journalism, and presented allegations as allegations rather than facts. However, the court rejected the BBC's defense, concluding that their reporting was not fair or responsible.
The case was brought forward in Dublin as the BBC Spotlight program was viewable in Ireland, where it was watched by approximately 16,000 people. The online article also garnered around 700 hits from viewers in Ireland throughout a 14-month period following its publication in September 2016.
The announcement of Gerry Adams' victory in the libel lawsuit against the BBC about the 2016 BBC Spotlight documentary and article has been classified as breaking news in the field of politics and general-news. The war of words between Adams and the BBC, fueled by accusations of poor journalistic practices and unproven allegations in the documentary, has finally concluded, with Adams being awarded significant damages.
%20in%20compensation.){kind=link}