Football coaches from ACC express support for modifications in the College Football Playoff (CFP) selection procedure
The College Football Playoff (CFP) is set for a significant change in its seeding policy for the 2025 season, moving from a 4-team playoff to a 12-team expanded playoff with automatic bids to five conference champions and seven at-large bids under a straight seeding model. This shift aims to address past criticisms of bias and imbalance in the field.
Key Features of the New Seeding Policy
The new CFP policy introduces several key changes:
- 12-team playoff: An expansion from the previous format, aiming to provide more opportunities for deserving teams.
- Five automatic bids: Awarded to the champions of the ACC, Big 12, Big Ten, SEC, and the highest-ranked Group of Six conference champion.
- Seven at-large bids: Selected without the need to be conference champions, allowing for a more competitive field.
- Straight seeding by overall CFP rankings: The top four teams receive first-round byes, regardless of conference championship status.
Comparison to Previous Years
The old CFP format, which ran from 2014 to 2022, heavily prioritized conference champions for top seeds but imposed limitations that often skewed fairness and balance. The initial 12-team proposal had restrictions that led to non-competitive or less deserving teams getting high seeds, causing imbalance. The new 12-team model eliminates these restrictions, aiming for a fairer and more competitive tournament.
Expanded Playoff and Multiple Autobids Discussion
There is ongoing debate about moving to a 16-team playoff system, which would allow even more teams to qualify and possibly include multiple automatic bids for certain conferences, especially larger ones like the SEC and Big Ten. The SEC and Big Ten have proposed their own ideas for such a system, but final agreements are still pending due to logistical concerns.
Notable Criticisms and Proposed Changes
The BCS system, used from 1998 to 2013, faced criticism for its methodology and exclusionary nature, leading to an antitrust lawsuit. The new CFP policy aims to address these issues by promoting a fairer and more inclusive system. Some coaches, such as Dave Doeren and Rhett Lashlee, have called for the selection process to be based on factors such as number of wins, strength of schedule, quality wins, and other similar factors, with no human interference.
Florida State was left out of the 2023 playoff despite going 13-0 and winning the ACC title, in part due to quarterback Jordan Travis' injury. This incident further highlighted the need for a fairer and more transparent selection process.
In conclusion, the CFP has evolved from a restrictive 4-team tournament into a more inclusive 12-team playoff with automatic bids, and the newest policies seek to eliminate arbitrary seeding constraints to reward the best teams more fairly. Discussions continue about expanding to 16 teams with multiple autobids per conference, but final agreements are pending.
1) The 12-team expanded College Football Playoff (CFP) for the 2025 season will be a significant shift from the previous 4-team format, offering more opportunities for deserving teams, particularly those who are Champions of ACC, Big 12, Big Ten, SEC, and the highest-ranked Group of Six conference champion.
2) Under the new CFP policy, the champions of conferences like the SEC and Big Ten may have a higher chance of securing a spot in the expanded 12-team playoff, as the proposal for a potential 16-team playoff system includes multiple automatic bids for larger conferences.
%20selection%20procedure){kind=link}