Film edits completed as per Censor Board's instructions on objectionable content from movie "Udaipur Files"; Delhi High Court mandates a special screening of the adjusted version.
The Delhi High Court is currently deliberating over a petition filed by Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind and others, seeking a stay on the release of the film "Udaipur Files." The film, scheduled for release on July 11, has sparked controversy due to allegations of promoting communal disharmony and hate speech.
The petition argues that the trailer portrays the murder of Sahu with the complicity of the leaders of the Muslim community, which could create a serious wedge between Hindus and Muslims. Critics claim that even with edited content, the film's intent remains problematic, potentially endangering public order.
The Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) cleared "Udaipur Files" after reportedly removing objectionable portions. The filmmakers claimed compliance with CBFC guidelines, but critics argue that the movie's overall narrative and trailer still sensationalize sensitive communal incidents and may fuel communal tensions.
Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, representing the petitioner, stated that the movie targets a particular community. However, ASG Sharma, representing the CBFC, assured the court that the offending portions have been taken down. The court has directed the petitioner to review the cuts and return on Thursday.
The legal challenge highlights the tension between freedom of expression and the need to protect public order and communal harmony. The Delhi High Court's decision to allow a private screening indicates a cautious approach, balancing these competing interests. The case underscores the complexities of film censorship in India, where the line between artistic freedom and social responsibility is often controversial.
The petition also claims that the movie portrays an entire community in a prejudicial manner, violating the right to live with dignity for its members. The petitioner is seeking directions to prohibit the release, distribution, broadcast, or public exhibition of the movie "Udaipur Files" and to remove the trailer from digital and social media platforms like YouTube, Facebook, and X.
Apart from the director, producer, and producer of the movie, Reliance Entertainment Pvt Ltd, Google, X, and Meta have been made parties to the case in the Delhi High Court. The outcome of this legal battle will have significant implications for the film industry and the broader society, as it navigates the delicate balance between artistic expression and social responsibility.
The petition raises concerns that the film "Udaipur Files" may exaggerate sensitive communal incidents, potentially stirring up political tensions and undermining general-news reporting about community harmony. Critics have noted that despite edited content, the overall entertainment value of the movie, as well as its portrayal of a specific community, could be problematic and damaging to public order.
