Reworted Article:
Title Swift: Should Trans Athletes Compete in Female Sports? US Masters Swimming in a Pickle Over Controversial Decision
Female swimmers express concern, file complaint: "I feel deceived"
In the world of competitive swimming, things just got a whole lot murkier. A report has surfaced claiming that former President Biden secretly harbored doubts about trans athletes competing in women's sports, and the latest fiasco involving U.S. Masters Swimming (USMS) only adds fuel to the fire.
Jennifer Sey, the founder of XX-XY Athletics, shares her frustrations over Washington State's failure to pass proposals protecting girls' sports, all while news of Biden's beliefs hits the press.
Last week, USMS found itself in the midst of a national uproar following revelations that a trans swimmer took home five women's events. The organization confirmed to our website, Digital, that an "eligibility review" is underway in response to a competitor's complaint at the meet.
Women's swimmer Wendy Enderle was one of the victims, falling behind trans athlete Ana Caldas at the USMS Spring National Championship in San Antonio. Enderle felt "betrayed" to learn that her long-time competitor was transgender.
"It makes me concerned, it makes me mad," Enderle tells Digital. She has since filed a request for eligibility review, hoping to keep Caldas out of the World Aquatics Masters World Championships in Singapore later this year.
Other USMS swimmers like Angie Griffin were unaware of Caldas' birth gender and have expressed their dissatisfaction. Griffin wrote a letter to USMS requesting a re-evaluation of the recent Spring National Championship and a complete overhaul of the gender eligibility policy.
Recent developments suggest that competitive swimming organizations like USMS are navigating complex jurisdictional challenges, with federal orders conflicting with state protections. The NCAA's evolving guidelines and Nevada's outright ban on trans athletes in female sports indicate a widening divide between inclusive and exclusionary approaches.
Most policies focus on hormone requirements for transgender women competitors, but specifics vary. To get the lowdown on USMS regulations, be sure to check out their latest policy documents. In the meantime, the debate rages on: should trans athletes compete in female sports? What do you think?
Video: See fellow swimmer Wendy Enderle share her thoughts on the incident, and check out Angie Griffin's heartfelt letter to USMS.
Related Coverage: Is Lia Thomas the New M.V.P. or a Source of Controversy? Riley Gaines Expresses Her Thoughts On Trans Athletes And Women's Sports
Stay tuned to Digital's sports coverage on Sports Huddle, and don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter for the latest updates!
[Writer's note: Federal policy, state-level actions, NCAA and collegiate athletics policies, and best practices are provided in the Enrichment Data should you wish to learn more.]
- The controversy surrounding transgender athletes competing in women's sports has moved beyond competitive swimming, with the NCAA's evolving guidelines and Nevada's ban on trans athletes in female sports further complicating the issue.
- Angie Griffin, another USMS swimmer, has also expressed her dissatisfaction over the participation of transgender athletes, writing a heartfelt letter to USMS requesting a re-evaluation of their gender eligibility policy.
- Lia Thomas, a transgender swimmer in collegiate athletics, has become a source of both admiration and controversy, sparking debates about fairness and inclusiveness in women's sports.
- As policies about transgender athletes in sports continue to evolve, focus has shifted to specific requirements such as hormone levels, with organizations like USMS offering documentation outlining their regulations for transgender competitors in their events.
