EU Leaders Critique China at Summit Over Taiwan and Ukraine Conflict
In the first face-to-face meeting between EU leaders and China's head of state in over four years, concerns arose surrounding rising tensions concerning Taiwan and China's increased military presence in contested areas of the South China Sea. Following the summit, Michel shared that he was confident Beijing was fully aware of the severe consequences of an escalation in the region.
Michel expressed hope that China would exert pressure on Russia to cease its aggression against Ukraine. The EU appealed to Beijing to adopt a more assertive stance on this matter. Commission President von der Leyen made clear that China's stance on Ukraine would shape its relationship with the EU.
However, China's Foreign Ministry maintained that Putin would decide on the basis of Russia's national interest and security, and the EU would not be influencing China's decision-making regarding Moscow.
Diverging views on mutual trade relations were also a topic of discussion, with von der Leyen pleasingly noting an agreement to establish a balanced portfolio between the EU and China. Contrastingly, Wang stated that he did not believe China should bear responsibility for the EU's trade deficit.
Complex and communicative negotiations between the EU and China are essential for establishing a stable and constructive partnership. While sharing various interests, such as cooperating on climate policy and artificial intelligence, both the EU and China underscore the need for frank and open discussions.
The summit was overshadowed by Italy's withdrawal from the Chinese New Silk Road investment initiative, which emerged just days before the gathering. The EU's third-largest economy was the sole G7 participant in this project led by Xi. Initiated in 2013, the New Silk Road has resulted in the construction of ports, railroads, airports, and industrial parks, primarily in Asia, Africa, and Europe, with the objective of enhancing China's entry into global markets.
Beijing's Foreign Ministry spokesperson Wang defended the New Silk Road against accusations of indebtedness and division, reinforcing that China would "resolutely oppose the slander and undermining of cooperation" in the project.
Exploring the Nuances of EU-China Relations
The intricate and multifaceted nature of the EU's stance on China's involvement in the Taiwan and Ukraine conflicts influences its trade relationships and overall partnership in various ways:
Taiwan
- Securing Critical Supplies: The EU is focusing on securing sources of critical supplies, particularly semiconductors, by diversifying its partnerships. Taiwan, as a democratic country and a significant producer of semiconductors, represents an attractive alternative aligned with EU values.
- Economic Partnership Agreements: The EU is considering an economic partnership agreement with Taiwan, which would strengthen their commercial and financial ties. This deal is driven by EU efforts to attain strategic autonomy in its trade policy and promote sustainable commerce and trade standards.
- Chinese Economic Coercion: Should the EU deepen its collaboration with Taiwan through strategies like the proposed RSCA and capital market connections, China may employ economic coercion to deter its involvement. Such measures generally backfire, resulting in diminishing trust in China and hastening the adoption of the EU Anti-Coercion Instrument.
Ukraine
- Geopolitical Consequences: The Ukraine conflict has amplified tensions between the EU and China, with the EU critical of China's stance on Ukraine, specifically its diplomatic support for Russia. This tension has negatively impacted their broader relationship.
- Economic Relations: The conflict has not immediately affected trade relations between the EU and China, but it has contributed to a sense of unease and mistrust. The EU is prioritizing cautious economic integration with China while maintaining its stance on Ukraine and other worldwide issues.
- Strategic Autonomy: The EU's emphasis on strategic autonomy in its trade policy is partly driven by the desire to address the geopolitical complexities associated with Ukraine. By pursuing diversification and ethical trade standards, the EU seeks to tackle the challenges posed by China's ascent.
Overall Relationship
- Considered Partnership: The EU-China relationship is marked by a delicate harmony between economic interdependence and ideological and strategic tensions. The EU is committed to maintaining cooperation while confronting asymmetries in the partnership, such as Beijing's industrial policies and trade practices.
- Regulatory Overview: The EU has toughened its regulatory scrutiny of Chinese firms, particularly in the e-commerce sector, due to concerns over product safety and market distortions. This includes the examination of platforms like Shein and Temu and the enactment of new regulations targeted at Chinese firms.
- Strategic Engagement: New cross-regional working groups have been established to enhance resilience and encourage dialogue on sectors like agriculture, aviation, artificial intelligence, energy, and finance. The EU is focusing on fostering this collaborative environment.