Finances: Europe greenlights ten billion for Hungary amidst controversy
Despite persistent criticisms of Hungary's rule of law by the European Parliament, the European Commission has decided to unfreeze a substantial ten billion euros in EU funds for the nation. The release of these funds comes after Hungary's fulfillment of necessary requirements, as per the EU Justice Commissioner, Didier Reynders.
Reynders pointed out that Hungary had met all agreed-upon reforms in the latest judicial reforms. As a result, the Commission believes that the independence of the judiciary in Hungary has strengthened, offering "sufficient guarantees." However, the Commission reiterates that this decision is not the final word on the matter. The situation will continue to be closely monitored, and appropriate actions will be taken in case of any setbacks.
Hungary's Veto Threat
The EU is preparing for a major summit in Brussels. At this event, leaders will discuss the commencement of EU accession negotiations with Ukraine and the long-term EU budget for the 2021-2027 period. Hungary's Prime Minister, Viktor Orban, has threatened to veto both issues.
Orban has raised concerns regarding the European Commission's proposal for EU accession negotiations, asserting that it violates a summit decision from June 2022. According to Orban, the proposal contradicts the decision's requirement for full reform compliance before taking further steps in the accession process.
However, it remains unclear if Orban is using this threat to secure the release of blocked subsidies for Hungary. Some EU diplomats believe this may be the case, while others argue that Orban will maintain his stance on Ukraine even after the release of funds.
EU Parliament's Reaction
The European Parliament has harshly criticized the EU Commission's decision to release the ten billion euros. Green MEP Daniel Freund accused Commission President Ursula von der Leyen of paying a "historic bribe" to Orban, a "Putin ally." Furthermore, leaders from the Christian Democrat, Social Democrat, and Liberal groups in the European Parliament condemned the Commission's move as unjustified.
The EU Commission, however, defended its decision, stating that they were vulnerable to continued fund withholding if they did not follow through on the recent Hungarian reforms. Nonetheless, the Commission acknowledges the timing of the decision creates the appearance of a connection to Hungary's veto threats.
Fund Suspension
The EU has withheld substantial portions of Hungary's EU funding, with concerns regarding corruption and upholding the rule of law under Prime Minister Orban. The Commission has accused Hungary of undermining EU standards and fundamental values for years.
The European Commission has initiated infringement proceedings against Hungary several times and brought the country to the European Court of Justice (ECJ). Currently, the Commission is withholding 22 billion euros in funding due to these concerns. Despite the ongoing controversy, the European Commission has not yet released the full ten billion euros for Hungary as per the media reports.
Relevant Details
The European Commission's decision to release a portion of the frozen EU funds for Hungary has sparked debate and criticism. Some view this as a crucial step towards resolving the ongoing tensions between Hungary and the EU, while others see it as a capitulation to Orban's demands. Regardless of the interpretation, the future of the relationship between Hungary and the EU remains uncertain, with potential consequences for both parties.
Source:
Additional Insights:
- Amidst the controversy, the European Commission aims to address Hungary's alleged violations of EU law by referring the country to the ECJ several times. This move signals the EU's determination to uphold its democratic standards and values in Hungary and other member states.
- The decision to partially release funds for Hungary has raised concerns about the EU's commitment to promoting the rule of law and combating corruption. Many see this as a significant step back from the EU's stance on these critical issues.
- The ongoing tensions between Hungary and the EU are not unique to Hungary, with other EU nations, such as Poland, also facing legal action and potential funding cuts due to concerns regarding the rule of law and democratic standards. These disputes highlight the broader challenges facing the EU in maintaining its core values and principles.
