Skip to content

"Establishing an Ill-Advised Precedent - For the Utterly Misguided"

Afghans File Lawsuit Against the Federation

"Example to be Demonstrated - In a Completely Incorrect Manner"
"Example to be Demonstrated - In a Completely Incorrect Manner"

"Establishing an Ill-Advised Precedent - For the Utterly Misguided"

Want to Know More? Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Email Print Copy Link

In a storm of court battles, Afghan refugees stranded in Pakistan find themselves in the precarious position of potential deportation, thanks to Germany's halt on admission programs. These efforts were initially launched during the previous government under the federal admission program, designed to facilitate legal migration for endangered individuals before the Taliban's takeover. Now, these citizens of Afghanistan face uncertainty, stuck in Pakistan with looming threats of being sent back to their home where safety is nonexistent.

Tilmann Röder, a legal professional and head of NGO Just Peace, is part of the team lighting up the German courts on behalf of the stranded Afghan men and women. In an exclusive interview with n-tv.de, Röder discusses the nitty-gritty of legal action and why he regards the federal government's actions as politically motivated.

ntv.de: Courtroom Clash: 25 Afghan Cases for Entry to Germany

What exactly are the legal battles about?

In essence, these lawsuits aim to secure visas for individuals in desperate need of protection who should no longer face barriers in their departure to Germany. They have successfully completed the steps of the federal admission program. A case example is a scientist and activist from Afghanistan, who actively campaigned for democracy before the Taliban crisis. Having been a target due to her political activism, she seeks the federal government's permission to enter Germany. The legal team strongly believes that the courts will demand Germany’s fulfillment of its promises to these refugees.

Immersed in the Federal Admission Process

The federal admission program was established in response to the Taliban's control in 2021. Its purpose was to enable legal migration for particularly vulnerable people, without putting them at risk or enforcing perilous journeys. Tilmann Röder, being the head of case processing in the coordination office of civil society within the federal admission program, played a significant role in this program. The coordination office was responsible for selecting especially endangered Afghan men and women, who were then assessed further by German authorities.

Who Were Chosen?

The target group for the federal admission program included individuals from Afghan civil society involved in transitioning Afghanistan towards democracy, rule of law, human rights, and freedom. This group also encompassed particularly vulnerable individuals such as women and the LGBTQIA community. Approximately half of the 2400 Afghan refugees presently stranded in Pakistan come from this admission program. The others are from the local forces procedure, the human rights list, or the bridging program.

A Grand Union Push to Revoke All Admission Programs

Despite the strong protection provided to these individuals under the federal admission program, the federal government now intends to reevaluate each case individually for security reasons. While possible, it seems unlikely and may come across as a brash excuse to rescind the admission offers.

Playing Politics?

It is abundantly clear to Tilmann Röder that the government is setting a political example. However, this example is misguided, as the targeted group holds values embodying the rule of law, democracy, freedom, and human rights. Moreover, Germany has made a solemn commitment as a nation to these individuals, and revoking these promises would be disastrous, damaging the nation's international reputation.

A Tumultuous Existence of Uncertainty

These Afghan refugees are subject to immense pressure, living in limbo, with the constant threat of deportation. The Pakistani government is also leading a crackdown on Afghan refugees, even those with visas may soon face expulsion. The Afghan refugees describe being kept in inhumane conditions, barely daring to step out of housing due to the imminent danger they face. Yet, they express resolve, adamant that they will not voluntarily return to Afghanistan.

Interview by Tilmann Röder, Marc Dimpfel

Source: ntv.de

  • Emotional Appeal: A tragic series of events unfolds as Afghan refugees find themselves stuck in Pakistan, facing the cruel possibility of deportation to their war-torn homeland. By standing firm in their pursuit of sanctuary, these brave souls battled against the odds and took the German government to court, seeking justice, safety, and a chance at a new life.
  • Key Words:
  • Germany
  • Afghan refugees
  • Admission program
  • Pakistan
  • Taliban
  • Legal battles
  • Politics
  • Reputation
  • Safety
  • Courage
  1. The legal battles in Germany surrounding Afghan refugees involve challenging the government's employment policy, as these refugees are seeking visas to migrate legally and avoid barriers in their departure, which is part of the general-news and crime-and-justice categories.
  2. Tilmann Röder, a legal professional and head of NGO Just Peace, believes that the federal government's actions towards Afghan refugees, such as the reevaluation of cases and the potential revocation of the admission program, are politically motivated and could negatively impact Germany's community policy and international reputation.

Read also:

Latest