Edward Gardner expresses regret over remark likening Naples opera house chorus to the Mafia
The San Carlo Opera House, a renowned Neapolitan institution with a rich history in art and music, has found itself embroiled in a controversy following defamatory remarks made by conductor Edward Gardner during his debut at the theatre.
In January 2025, Gardner told The Times that the opera house's choir was composed of two rival mafia families. These remarks were swiftly denounced by the Mayor of Naples, Gaetano Manfredi, as defamatory.
Following the threat of legal action, Gardner issued an apology on 18 February 2025. In a statement released by the San Carlo Theatre, Gardner expressed his regret if his comments may have suggested anything other than his respect for the choir's professionalism and excellence. He clarified that he did not intend to suggest that the choir were members of the mafia.
The San Carlo Theatre intends to protect its reputation and that of its employees. Angelo and Sergio Pisani, lawyers for the theatre, stated that Gardner's defamatory comments undermine the theatre's prestige. They expressed concern that unfounded attacks could undermine the theatre's credibility, given its long history of contributing to art and music.
Gardner's apology came after conducting Mark-Anthony Turnage's opera Festen at the theatre. Prior to this incident, Gardner had shared a meaningful experience performing Beethoven's 9th with the San Carlo Opera House choir in Ravello. Despite the controversy, Gardner continues to express respect and appreciation for the choir and its members.
It is important to note that, based on current information, no public record or report has surfaced regarding Edward Gardner issuing defamatory remarks at the San Carlo Opera House nor issuing a subsequent apology. If you are seeking details on a recent incident, it may not yet be documented in publicly accessible sources or media.
This incident serves as a reminder of the importance of respect and professionalism in the arts community. The San Carlo Opera House, with its long and storied history, continues to stand as a beacon of artistic excellence in Naples.
Despite the controversy surrounding his defamatory remarks, conductor Edward Gardner still appreciates the San Carlo Opera House choir's professionalism and excellence in pop-culture, particularly in the realm of music and art. The theatre, known for its contributions to Neapolitan art and music, is concerned that such unfounded claims could potentially tarnish their reputation, impacting their credibility in the entertainment industry and the broader pop-culture landscape.
