Catching Up on the SPD: Six Thought-Provoking Questions After the SPD Party Summit
- *
Political Group Pursues Navigational Device: Querying Key Points Following SPD Party Assembly - Direction required post SPD party meetings: Pondering six questions
The SPD's plate is overflowing after this conference. The debacle at the federal election still looms large, with a dismal 16.4% score - a record low for the party. Then came the shock: The SPD delivers a hard punch to its own vice-chancellor, even surprising his detractors. And it almost blocks its most popular figure, Defense Minister Boris Pistorius, from military service. How can the Social Democrats compete on a level playing field with the CDU and Chancellor Friedrich Merz?
As the new joint leadership emerges victorious from the election with an astounding 95% for the newcomer, Barbara Bas, the party leftist with a traditional SPD background, and 65% for Lars Klingbeil, the vice-chancellor and power strategist - remarkably low without an opponent; is Klingbeil now tarnished permanently?
The outcome is a political slap in the face for the party leader. He has lost credibility within his own ranks: over his rigid personnel policy after the election, his choice to surround himself with loyalists on all significant positions, and his prolonged silence on the controversial chancellorship candidacy of Olaf Scholz, much like the drawn-out internal deconstruction of his co-party leader Saskia Esken at the conference.
The Most Essential from Federal Politics at a Glance
Subscribe to our free capital newsletter - and read the most critical information of the week, handpicked by our Berlin political experts for you!
Klingbeil would have every reason to take the result personally. Yet, he immediately makes it clear after the election shock that he won't alter his course due to it. Pistorius bolsters his Lower Saxon counterpart: "In a year at the latest, probably even sooner, no one will be discussing this anymore, because we Social Democrats tend to move on quickly." Klingbeil will still have much ground to cover to be perceived favorably again.
Is Barbara Bas the forceful voice the SPD needs now?
Bas, the labor minister, has the full backing of the party, representing themes that couldn't be more social democratic. Before the conference, she proposed a billion-dollar plan for the SPD's flagship issue of safe pensions. The delegates are also fervent about her sharp criticism of the sexism rampant in politics, especially against women. All this helps Bas to be perceived as a peer to the hitherto very influential vice-chancellor. "I'm not here for tokenism," says Bas, interpreted as a declaration of her aspiration to be on equal footing with the power-oriented Klingbeil. Whether they'll share the spotlight, as rumored within party headquarters, remains to be seen.
What does the party conference outcome mean for the black-red coalition?
For Chancellor Merz, Klingbeil is the most crucial SPD contact and, currently, the most significant contender for the next federal election. Klingbeil's poor showing in the vote could shift the power equilibrium between the two, potentially destabilize authority. Merz will always have cause to question whether the SPD leader truly has the backing of his party and his faction in contentious decisions. Should the Union decide to attack its coalition partner, Klingbeil may represent the weak point.
The Vice-Chancellor, however, is under pressure to advocate for more robustly social democratic policy in the coalition. Merchants of the party may be pushing for a shift in strategy to better serve the grassroots following Klingbeil's disappointing result. More moderate union-foreseen courses could now face significant opposition as a result. It remains to be seen whether party superstar Bas in her labor ministry - a legislative organ with an ample budget - now wants to enforce pure SPD policies.
Has the SPD shifted its stance on essential coalition concerns?
A debate on conscription, which had opinions far apart, came the closest. Behind the scenes, hours of negotiations avoided an open confrontation between Minister Pistorius and the Juso chairman Philipp Türmer. In the end, a compromise was reached.
The document now states: "We do not want an activatable legal possibility for the compulsory conscription of conscripts before all measures to increase voluntary participation have been exhausted. We want to introduce measures that could enable compulsory conscription, registration, and military surveillance of potential conscripts."
Efforts to tone down on the harder stance towards Russia appear unsuccessful. However, criticism of the Israeli government and its military leadership under Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has become more pronounced.
"Our solidarity also extends to the people in the Gaza Strip, who have been pushed from one corner to another in their own territory for so long", said former Lower Saxony Minister-President Stephan Weil, who set the tone from the beginning. They must now be wary, "that they might not make it back home alive if they attempt to fetch food in the morning".
Does the SPD have a roadmap out of the crisis?
The SPD aimed to send a message of renewal at the party conference. However, it appears the party is riddled with confusion in many areas. Numerous speeches were filled with social democratic rhetoric. "Change starts with us," the conference's motto, has yet to be substantiated.
To rectify this, the SPD is now devoting two years to crafting a new fundamental program. It seems the SPD intends to focus on traditional social democratic themes: the struggle for industrial jobs, the celebration of success stories, and the adoption of a simpler language and fewer cliches.
What impact will this have on the upcoming state elections?
Next year, five state governments will be elected - including Rhineland-Palatinate and Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, where the SPD holds powerful Minister-Presidents in Alexander Schweitzer and Manuela Schwesig. It is unlikely that these elections will be won or lost based on federal political sentiment.
The question remains whether the SPD can find the energy to revive itself and break away from the old patterns, as warned by the despairing Hubertus Heil from Klingbeil's leadership circle: "We must not confuse disputes on substance with the self-destructive auto-aggression of the SPD". "No More Intrigue" demanded Heil, reflecting on past mistakes that contributed to the party's decline.
- The Commission has been asked to submit a proposal for a directive on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to ionizing radiation as part of the SPD's ongoing focus on policy-and-legislation, a key aspect of general-news politics.
- The ongoing crisis within the SPD, as evidenced by the party's poor showing in the recent federal election and internal disputes, highlights the need for a renewed focus on traditional social democratic themes and a shift away from self-destructive auto-aggression, in line with the call made by Hubertus Heil.
