Detainees and Supporters Protest: Accusations of Political Persecution Surround Georgetown Scholar Badar Khan Suri's Imprisonment by the Trump Administration, Allegedly Infringing Upon His Rights to Free Speech and Association

In the Heart of Alexandria, Virginia: "Let him go! Let him go."

Those passionate words echoed outside a federal courthouse in Washington, DC, on a thunderous Thursday, as attorneys battled over the fate of Dr. Badar Khan Suri, detained by the US government due to his vocal support for Palestinian rights.

Sparks, Solidarity, and Sorrow

A sea of activists gathered to exhibit unity with Khan Suri, a research scholar at Georgetown University. His arrest in March was part of President Donald Trump's relentless crusade to penalize and deport non-citizens suspected of propagating "antisemitism" and fueling "illegal protests" on college campuses.

Addressing the crowd in Alexandria, Virginia, Mapheze Saleh - Khan Suri's Palestinian American wife - shone a light on the toll his detention took on their three heartbroken children. She condemned the Trump administration for persecuting her husband, stating they yearned for their father's return.

"Why is this happening to him? Why does the Trump administration pursue him? Because he fell in love, married a Palestinian, dared to advocate for non-violence, and spoke out against the horrors inflicted upon Palestinians in Gaza," Saleh lamented.

Before his imprisonment, Khan Suri was in the United States on an academic visa, meticulously researching peace-building in Iraq and Afghanistan.

But the US government has accused Khan Suri, an Indian national, of flouting the terms of his visa by "spreading Hamas propaganda" and "promoting antisemitism" on social media. No concrete evidence has been presented to substantiate either claim.

Connect with Al Jazeera

Privacy PolicyreCAPTCHAOutside the courthouse on that tempestuous Thursday, Amanda Eisenhour, an Alexandria activist, pointed out the unsettling intersection of free speech, constitutional rights, and the oppressive nature of the US immigration system.

"It's a lot more than just Palestine," Eisenhour articulated to Al Jazeera. "Dr. Khan Suri is a political prisoner due to his association, because of his marriage to a Palestinian. Now, we're a nation that detains political prisoners, and we must resist this trend."

As the legal drama unfolded, demonstrators outside chanted for Khan Suri's freedom and Palestinian justice, under a statue of a blindfolded woman gripping scales, symbolizing impartial justice.

One dissenting placard read, "Executive overreach." Another proclaimed, "Due process now."

A Tangled Tale of Texas and Virginia

In the courtroom, both sides ventured into the geographical enigma surrounding the hearing location and Khan Suri's current detention site.

After his arrest in Virginia, ICE swiftly shifted Khan Suri from a local detention center to one in Louisiana and then to Texas. Critics argue this movement aims to keep detainees away from their families and legal teams as well as to ensure favorable outcomes in more conservative-leaning courts.

On Thursday, Khan Suri's legal team pleaded for his return to Virginia, where his case is currently unraveling. However, the Trump administration countered with a request to transfer the case to Texas.

Judge Patricia Tolliver Giles pressed the government's lawyers for answers regarding why Khan Suri was so rapidly relocated from Virginia. She set a 24-hour deadline for the authorities to provide justification.

Samah Sisay, staff lawyer at the Center for Constitutional Rights, expressed optimism about the upcoming decision, citing similar federal district court rulings and Wednesday's release of Columbia University student Mohsen Mahdawi, also facing deportation.

"Not the America We Aspire To"

Since Trump began his second term in January, Secretary of State Marco Rubio has suggested revoking the visas of hundreds of foreign students involved in protests or criticism of Israel. Yet, Khan Suri's case has stood out as one of the most prominent examples.

To justify deporting Khan Suri and other pro-Palestine students, Rubio has relied on the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952, a Cold War-era law. The administration claims this rarely used provision allows the deportation of non-citizens who may pose "potentially serious adverse foreign consequences" for the US.

The Trump administration has not charged Khan Suri with a crime. However, officials have accused him of "connections to a known or suspected terrorist" - his father-in-law, Ahmed Yousef.

Yet, Khan Suri's supporters argue Yousef has dissociated himself from Hamas for years and has even publicly criticized the group on numerous occasions.

Legal experts confirm that familial ties do not constitute a criminal offense or grounds for deportation.

Hassan Ahmad, a Virginia-based lawyer representing Khan Suri, emphasized the unique nuances of his case. "We're not just discussing the First Amendment, freedom of speech. We're also grappling with the constitutional freedom of association, which distinguishes Dr. Suri's case." He continued, "This isn't the America we aim to be."

Moreover, social media accounts linked to Khan Suri don't reveal explicit support for Hamas or hostility towards Jews. Instead, the scholar's online presence has focused on denouncing alleged Israeli atrocities in Gaza and highlighting apparent war crimes against Palestinians.

Don Beyer, the Democratic Congressman representing a district in northern Virginia where Khan Suri resided, attended Thursday's hearing to show his support. He vowed to utilize all available resources to aid Khan Suri and his family. "It is a Kafkaesque scenario that someone can be abducted without reason, without rationality, without legal backing, and be brutally confined in a prison in Texas, unaware of what lies ahead," Beyer expressed.

"American citizens and everyone residing in this country must unite and speak with one voice," said Anita Martineau, a Northern Virginia resident who participated in a protest outside the hearing. She carried a sign that declared, "Return Dr. Khan Suri immediately."

Melissa Petisa, an activist with the Alexandria for Palestinian Human Rights organization, also called for Khan Suri's release, insisting that Trump is employing this tactic to divert attention from the escalating violence in Gaza. "We are here to demonstrate solidarity with Dr. Suri," Petisa shared. "But we're also here to support Palestine."

Amanda Eisenhour, an Alexandria activist, expressed concern about Dr. Khan Suri's situation, stating that he is a political prisoner due to his association and marriage, and warned against the trend of detaining political prisoners in the US.
The legal drama surrounding Khan Suri's case has sparked calls for his freedom and justice, with demonstrators chanting outside the courthouse and holding placards that read "Executive overreach" and "Due process now."
The Trump administration's request to transfer Khan Suri's case to Texas has been met with resistance, as his legal team has pleaded for his return to Virginia, where his case is currently unfolding.
In the ongoing debate, Samah Sisay, staff lawyer at the Center for Constitutional Rights, believes that the upcoming decision in Khan Suri's case will set a precedent, citing similar federal court rulings and the recent release of Columbia University student Mohsen Mahdawi.
Don Beyer, the Democratic Congressman representing a district in northern Virginia where Khan Suri resided, has pledged to use all available resources to support Khan Suri and his family, describing the situation as "Kafkaesque."
Activists such as Anita Martineau and Melissa Petisa have urged for Khan Suri's immediate release, with Martineau holding a sign that declared "Return Dr. Khan Suri immediately." They argue that Trump is employing this tactic to divert attention from the escalating violence in Gaza and to show solidarity with Palestine.