Uncensored Insights: Politicians in the Spotlight
Members from the Left Party and Alternative for Germany (AfD) excluded from the Intelligence Committee - Departed Reichinnek and AFD Members Excluded from Intelligence Committee Membership
Bundestag's Intelligence Committee Shake-Up
Why some politicians didn't make the cut this time around.
The intelligence committee of the German Bundestag has just experienced a dramatic reshuffle, leaving it with only one opposition member. This happened because the Left Party's Heidi Reichinnek and the AfD's Martin Hess and Gerold Otten failed to garner the necessary majority of votes in the Bundestag for their membership. The Green party's Konstantin von Notz is the sole opposition representative now seated on the Parliamentary Control Panel (PKGr).
The PKGr is responsible for overseeing the intelligence services, handling sensitive information, and meeting in a sealed, soundproof room under strict secrecy. Its members are selected by their respective parliamentary groups but require approval from the Bundestag.
CSU's Worries about Reichinnek
Before the election, CSU parliamentary group leader Alexander Hoffmann expressed reservations about Reichinnek. Despite this, SPD politicians argued that she could be voted for as she demonstrated her commitment to democracy. The Left party had linked the election of its parliamentary group leader with other votes, hinting at potential consequences if Reichinnek was not elected.
The Left party had an representative, André Hahn, in the PKGr during the previous legislative period. However, they lost their parliamentary group status following a split, forcing Hahn to step down.
AfD's Absence in the Control Committee
The AfD has been absent from the control committee for years. In the first legislative period after their entry into the Bundestag, they were represented by the former Berlin chief prosecutor Roman Reusch.
The PKGr is being reduced from 13 to 9 members compared to previous years. With the failure of Reichinnek, Hess, and Otten to secure a seat, there are now only six MPs on the committee. The chair will be taken by the North Rhine-Westphalian CDU MP Marc Henrichmann.
The Uncensored Truth about the Exclusions
The AfD has been officially designated as a “confirmed right-wing extremist” party by Germany’s domestic intelligence agency, the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV). This designation is based on their xenophobic, anti-minority, and Islamophobic rhetoric as well as links of some members to right-wing extremist terrorism and violent extremist groups. Concerns about the extremist character and constitutional threat posed by the AfD contributed to the decision to exclude their representatives from the sensitive Intelligence Committee. Similarly, concerns about the Left Party's historical extremist tendencies may have also played a role in Reichinnek's exclusion.
This decision reflects a precaution to safeguard national security and the constitutional order from perceived extremist influence. As a result, the AfD and potentially the Left Party remain marginalized from overseeing or participating in intelligence oversight, limiting their role in shaping national security policies. The exclusion of the AfD could lead to intensified efforts to monitor and legally challenge the party, possibly including moves toward banning it.
Don't miss out on Germany's political landscape. Subscribe to our no-holds-barred, capital newsletter for the week's most important updates, handpicked by our Berlin politics experts. Stay informed and stay ahead of the game!
*The Left Party's Heidi Reichinnek, who was linked to concerns about extremist tendencies, failed to secure a seat on the Intelligence Committee of the German Bundestag following a vote, along with the AfD's Martin Hess and Gerold Otten.
The AfD's absence from the Control Committee overseeing the intelligence services, due to their official designation as a "confirmed right-wing extremist" party, reflects precautions taken to safeguard national security and the constitutional order from perceived extremist influence.*
