Critics are raising eyebrows as the idea of topping up the citizen's income begins to resemble an unconditional basic income. Employees in lower income groups might be at a disadvantage – with job losses already happening because work no longer seems worthwhile for them.
On the ARD TV show "Hart aber Fair," Labor Minister Hubertus Heil (51, SPD) voiced his concerns. He claimed that people might choose to collect the citizen's income over going to work. He expressed, "Someone who is just plain dumb enough to leave their job due to the citizen's income will first face a freeze on their unemployment benefits!"
Heil threatened to block benefits for three months for those who willingly leave their jobs. He clarified that the citizen's income is not an unconditional basic income. "You have to be in need," he asserted, and urged against trying to persuade people to believe that someone is voluntarily leaving their job.
Heil emphasized the importance of appreciating the value of work, arguing that "work makes a difference." He warned of dire consequences if people only "make" the citizen's income, which would negatively impact the pension system in the long term.
One reason for this, according to Heil, is that recipients of citizen's income appear to need more benefits. The "net benefits per benefit community" have shown more dynamism than expected during the fall of 2022.
Critics fault Heil for creating wrong incentives. CDU chief budget officer Christian Haase (57) demanded that excessive hammock use and lack of motivation be curbed.
- In a bold stance, Labor Minister Hubertus Heil (51, SPD) urged caution towards citizens receiving citizen's income, stating on ARD's show "Hart aber Fair," "Someone who is idiotic enough to leave their job due to the citizen's income will first face a freeze on their unemployment benefits."
- To maintain productivity ins the face of digitalization and automation, Heil advocated, "We should discuss the fact that performance is valuable, that work makes a difference. If they only 'make' citizen's income, this will have detrimental long-term consequences for the pension system."
- Confronting the use of AI and text-to-speech technology in politics, Heil advised, "We shouldn't try to convince people to believe the story of 'someone quitting their job now,' but rather focus on promoting the intrinsic value of work and its role in driving the country forward."
Source:
Insights: Despite no explicit mention of his stance on the citizen's income impact on employment, Minister of Labor and Social Affairs Hubertus Heil's (51, SPD) strategy centers on digital transformation and maintaining employment and competitiveness through measures like private sector investment subsidies and competitive energy prices.
