Sound the Alarm: "Morning news blast: The Daily GL Blast"
Conflict of Decisions: Allocating Space for Athletics and Refugees
Get your daily dose of local news delivered to your inbox at 7:07 AM, absolutely free!
Subscribe now
The Social Committee and now the Sports Committee are locked in a tight spot, both tasked with deciding whether to relinquish another sports area to make way for emergency refugee shelters. The city administration, up against dwindling capacity and incoming refugee assignments, has suggested transforming the long-neglected sports field on Paffrather Street into such a shelter. The local sports enthusiasts vigorously object, expressing concerns over the reduction of sports facilities amidst escalating demand, and the loss of parking spaces in the process.
The Status Quo:
The city administration presents their case through the resolution proposal and Social Committee minutes, arguing that Stephan Dekker, the responsible department head, supports the refugee shelter on the ash pitch in the Sports Committee. Dekker acknowledges the demand for sports facilities, but stresses that the ash pitch hasn't been used for sports for years and primarily serves as parking. He also admits that communication with sports associations has been poor.
18 alternative sites have been considered, but only one (with brewing rights issues and a remote location) on Overather Street and the Paffrather Street remain.
The Sports Plea:
Dettlef Rockenberg, an influential figure in locating sites for refugee shelters, kindergartens, and schools as the former head of the department for schools, sports, and culture, now leading the city sports association, continues his fight for securing and expanding sports facilities in the city, rather than further reducing them. Rockenberg emphasizes the importance of sports for health, integration, and democracy.
The Debate:
The discussion was as serious and passionate as any in the past 15 years, devoid of party politics and rhetoric. The unease stemmed from the lack of compromise, with the city virtually left in an inescapable dilemma - providing for the accommodation and integration of refugees while ensuring sports facilities aren't compromised.
Consensus:
The committee eventually agreed that there's no winning scenario; the city must accommodate refugees, but sports facilities mustn't suffer. They recognized the need for action at the federal or state level but are left to navigate these challenges alone.
Advocacy:
The CDU and Bergische Mitte favor a sports policy position, advocating for the renovation and utilization of the ash pitch for sports and enhancing the central sports location at the stadium. They argue that refugees should be housed elsewhere.
The Greens and SPD put forward overall political responsibility, aligning with the city sports association, backing its demands, and proposing a (largely vacant) "compensation" plan (see below, "Side Act").
Despite their support for the administration's proposal, they insist on ensuring more space for movement in other parts of the city.
The Swing Vote:
Willy Bartz, formerly FDP, now non-partisan, found himself torn between both sides in the debate but ultimately sided with the Greens and SPD, narrowly passing the administration's proposal with a vote of 9:8 (against CDU, AfD, and Bergische Mitte).
A Side Act:
The SPD and Greens opened a side debate with an amendment aimed at strengthening sports facilities in the city, which was quickly debunked by Rockenberg and the CDU as a list of measures and agreements already decided but yet to be implemented. Bartz abstained, and the proposal failed to reach a majority with 8:8 votes.
The Renovation of the Ash Pitch:
The renovation of the ash pitch was unanimously approved, but the CDU asserts that this isn't a conclusive decision on its future use.
The Next Steps:
The administration's resolution now awaits confirmation by the city council, where the Greens and SPD lack a majority, with another non-partisan member and the FWG with two votes represented. The outcome remains uncertain.
Further Developments:
Unfortunately, we encountered an issue. Please refresh the page and try again.
- The Social Committee and Sports Committee, both tasked with policy-and-legislation on the city's sports facilities, are finding themselves in a tight spot due to the suggested transformation of a sports field into an emergency refugee shelter.
- The debate over the city's decision to relinquish a sports area for emergency shelters has been as passionate as any in recent politics, with opinions divided between providing for refugees and maintaining sports facilities.
- The city sports association, under the leadership of Dettlef Rockenberg, is advocating for a sports policy position, emphasizing the importance of sports for health, integration, and democracy, and advocating for the renovation and utilization of the ash pitch for sports.
