Comparison of Recent Struggles: Yankees or Mets – Which New York Baseball Team is Faring Worse at present?
New York Mets and Yankees Suffer Simultaneous Slump
In the world of Major League Baseball, the New York Mets and Yankees have been facing a challenging period. Over the past two months, both teams have experienced a notable downturn in performance, with the Mets losing 11 of their last 12 games and the Yankees struggling to maintain their playoff spot [1].
Mets' Struggles
The Mets, who started the season strong with a record of 45-24, have seen a sharp decline, going 19-34 in the subsequent stretch. Their struggles can be attributed to a number of factors, including poor bullpen performance, inability to hold leads, and inconsistent execution despite having elite pitching talent. Manager Carlos Mendoza has acknowledged the difficulty in pinpointing the exact causes, though strategic inconsistency and pressure appear to be key factors [3][4].
Yankees' Slump
The Yankees, too, have regressed into one of the worst-performing teams over the past two months. They have been unable to secure "normal" losses, instead experiencing demoralizing defeats that have contributed to their slide in the standings [1].
Current Standings
As of early August 2025, the Mets are 63-55 overall, five games behind the Phillies in the NL East and fighting for the third wild-card spot amid competition from teams like Cincinnati [2]. The Yankees are hanging on to the last playoff spot in the American League, but have fallen significantly in recent weeks [2].
Key Moments
- The Mets lost a walk-off game on Sunday, with the score being 7-6 in favour of the Brewers [1].
- The Yankees were no-hit into the sixth inning by Jason Alexander on Sunday [1].
- The Mets have had a starter go six innings only eight times in their last 53 games, with all eight instances being David Peterson [1].
- The Mets have the lowest runs per game (3.92) since June 13, ranking 30th in MLB [1].
- The Yankees have the 14th highest runs per game (4.58) since June 13, but the 26th lowest runs allowed per game (5.02) [1].
Summary
Both New York MLB teams, initially considered World Series contenders, have suffered intense performance downturns with overlapping losing streaks rarely seen in nearly 30 years. These simultaneous slumps are driven by a combination of strategic errors, bullpen weaknesses, pressure-induced inconsistencies, and a loss of momentum. The Mets' bullpen and late-game failures feature prominently as causes, while the Yankees have also struggled broadly on the field [1][3][4].
This situation has led to a notable slide in the standings for both teams, underscoring a challenging stretch for New York baseball in mid-2025.
Pete Alonso is currently batting at .639, while Francisco Lindor is at .510. Juan Soto has a .741 OPS since the All-Star break.
Boone, the Yankees manager, stated that they've had two bad months and haven't performed at a level they need to.
The Mets' position player WAR is 4.0, ranking 24th, while the Yankees' is 6.2, ranking 14th.
Devin Williams has two blown saves and two losses in his last five outings, despite being continually used in close games by Boone.
The Mets are down 1-2 in the season series for the Reds, making the tiebreaker less favorable.
Aaron Judge has a .631 OPS since the All-Star break.
The Guardians are likely to get the tiebreaker over the Yankees because of their better record within division.
In the Mid-2025 MLB season, the Mets' record has plummeted from a strong start, with a current standing of 63-55, five games behind the Phillies in the NL East, leading fans to question their World Series contender status [2].
The Yankees, too, have seen their record deteriorate, placing them in a precarious position as they hang on to the last playoff spot in the American League, with a notable struggle since June 13, particularly in terms of runs per game [1].
With the Mets' bullpen underperforming and the Yankees plagued by broad field difficulties, both teams have seen demoralizing defeats and overlapping losing streaks, possibly influencing their bettors' decisions in the world of sports [1].
Pete Alonso and Francisco Lindor are currently batting with impressive averages for the Mets, but the team's overall WAR ranks 24th among all MLB teams [3].
On the Yankees' side, Aaron Judge's post-All-Star break OPS has dropped significantly, echoing the team's struggles [4].
The simultaneous slumps experienced by the Mets and Yankees have become a topic of interest among fans and sports analysts alike, as the two New York teams strive to turn the tide and potentially secure a win in their remaining games this season [5].
