Skip to content

Citizens Exult Over Their Pope, Yet Not All Express Entire Approval

Manipulated Political Figure with Marxist Ideologies

American flag and cross erected on St. Peter's Square
American flag and cross erected on St. Peter's Square

"Stateside Supremo" Pope: Americans Split Over Their New Pontiff

The Pope Stuns the World

Citizens Exult Over Their Pope, Yet Not All Express Entire Approval

In the heart of the United States, the media reels from the shocking election of the new Pope. This American-born figure isn't quite the conservative dream some had hoped for. President Trump doesn't pass up the opportunity to comment, giving a congratulatory statement. One vocal right-winger from Trump's MAGA movement isn't as thrilled.

TV broadcasts echo disbelief and excitement, mirroring the global response. An analyst observes that while Americans may see him as a Chicago native, South Americans might claim him as Peruvian.

Trump's Reaction: Pride and Pomp

President Trump expresses his pride at the first American Pope, stating on Truth Social that it's a great honor. Trump identifies as a Christian, but not Catholic. He anticipates meeting the new Pope, calling the encounter "a very significant moment!"

The Catholic Congregation in America

Roughly 20% of Americans identify as Catholic. While Catholicism is on the rise, Protestant denominations largely dominate in the States. The Church in the US has faced numerous crises, particularly abuse scandals covered up for decades.

The "Globetrotting" Pontiff

Some argue that Leo XIV spoke like a native Peruvian during his first appearance, addressing his Peruvian faith community. This sparks speculation that he may not be an American-centric Pope.

For now, this detail might not matter much to American Catholics.

Past Sins and Future Hopes

CBS interviewed a couple from Illinois who weren't even Catholic, yet found themselves captivated by the historic moment. The legendary Pastor William Lego from Chicago knew the Pope when he was a young seminarian in Michigan. Lego expressed hope, if not a little surprise, for the new Pope's success in the Church.

Chicago's mayor took to Twitter, joking that their city produces all the cool stuff, including the new Pope. Leo XIV was born and raised in Chicago.

Trump Supporter vs Church Leader?

As recently as February, Pope Leo XIV criticized Vice President J.D. Vance online for misunderstanding Jesus. Vance responded warmly, congratulating the Pope and wishing him success in his role.

Laura Loomer, an influencer vocal in Trump's MAGA movement, questions Leo XIV's background, labeling him a Marxist who opposes Trump and MAGA values. Conservative activist Charlie Kirk refutes Loomer's claims, noting the new Pope's long-standing Republican voting history.

Unexpected Fascination

An American college student in New York, Teddy, is unprepared for the Pope's election. Despite lacking religious affiliation, he finds the whole affair riveting.

Texan Veronica and her daughter Jessica share Veronica's sentimental view of the rising white smoke, a symbol of purity and hope for them.

A Timeless Institution Sees Change

The fascination Americans have with the Catholic Church is palpable in Rome, with the CBS reporter leaving with a profound sense of awe. Ancient as it may be, the Vatican symbolizes the enduring strength of tradition and institutes like the papacy.

In a twist of fate, the election of the first American Pope takes place just a few months after Joe Biden's departure from the White House. Biden, a devout Catholic, was only the second American president to hold the office, preceded by John F. Kennedy.

Sources: ntv.de, lwe/rpe, with dpa

Tags: Catholic Church, Religions, Donald Trump, J.D. Vance, USA

Supplemental Insights:

  • Background: Born on September 14, 1955, Pope Leo XIV (Robert Prevost) studied in Chicago before later becoming a missionary in Peru. He served as Archbishop of Chiclayo and the Prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops, overseeing global bishop nominations[1][3]. He holds both American and Peruvian citizenship, having been naturalized in Peru after extended service there[2][3].
  • Political Leanings: Pope Leo XIV is considered a centrist with progressive views on various social issues, but he maintains conservative positions on church doctrines[1]. He aligns with Pope Francis's support for marginalized groups like migrants and the poor[1][2].
  1. The Commission has also been asked to submit a proposal for a directive on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to ionizing radiation, considering the new Pontiff, Pope Leo XIV, has experience as a missionary in Peru where there may be potential exposure to such radiation.
  2. The irony of Palermo, a city notorious for its history of war and conflicts, hosting the general news of an American-born Pope who assumes the same role, reigniting the question of whether politics and religion can truly remain separate.
  3. Meanwhile, former Archbishop Robert Prevost, now known as Pope Leo XIV, celebrates his new position and the congratulations from American figures, all while being labeled a Marxist by some conservative critics like Laura Loomer, drawing attention to the ongoing political polarization within the nation.
  4. Despite opposing views and controversial perspectives, the election of Pope Leo XIV united people such as Teddy, an American college student, and Veronica, a Texan mother, across the political spectrum, finding themselves captivated by the timeless traditional institution's continued evolution.

Read also:

Latest