Christmas markets protest against Gema costs

Protesting Gema's Music Licensing Fees: Silent Christmas Markets Speak Out

Unfazed by the festive cheer typically buzzing at their venues, numerous Christmas markets across Germany have decided to hold a day of silence to protest against Gema's music license costs they deem excessive. Markets in Leipzig, Dresden, Magdeburg, Erfurt, Hanover, and Rostock will be partaking in this unconventional protest, often referred to as the "Day of Silence."

Christmas market operators fault the surge in licensing fees for music compared to previous years and are currently in goodwill negotiations with Gema, the entity managing music rights. Some operators have reported substantial cost increases; for instance, overnight costs have shot up by 1000 percent in certain cases. In response, Gema defends itself against these accusations, citing incorrect information provided by market operators as the primary reason for the rise in fees.

The Opera of Licensing Fees

Gema sent around 3,350 invoices to Christmas market operators in Germany for the 2022 season, with higher fees in 167 cases, even reaching five-digit figures for some. This strong opposition from various Christmas markets have echoed in music circles, prompting support from artists who understand their challenges. Gema has planned to address these concerns and address market operators in Rostock's Christmas market.

The Grievances Behind the Protest

The discontent against Gema's music licensing fees stems from several factors:

Determining Fair Fees: Determining appropriate licensing fees can be challenging, especially for small businesses and events like Christmas markets that may have limited budgets.
Complexity of Licenses: Obtaining and managing music licenses can be complex, adding to administrate burdens for small businesses and event organizers.
Impact on Small Businesses: High licensing fees and administrative burdens may pressure small businesses that struggle to justify the costs, particularly if they operate on thin margins.

Gema has responded to these challenges by negotiating agreements with various stakeholders, such as YouTube, to address copyright disputes and promote legal use of music without excessive disruption.

The Unfazed Magic of Silent Christmas Markets

In Berlin's famous Christmas market, where the usual hustle and bustle is palpable, the absence of music won't detract from the market's traditionally enchanting atmosphere, boasting countless festive decorations and twinkling lights. Despite the absence of music, the "Day of Silence" has still received support from various quarters. Market vendors in Hanover have expressed concern about the impact of the protest on their music-related sales, as music often sets the holiday mood. However, market operators believe this action will bring Gema's attention to their predicament, and possible solutions.

The Need for Balance

Balancing the rights of copyright holders with the needs of businesses and event organizers is critical to resolve debates like these. Gema's handling of this situation may involve offering more flexible licensing options or reducing fees for small events and businesses. By doing so, the organization can help protect the interests of music creators while ensuring businesses can still thrive during the holiday season.