Casinos in Macau may consider retreating as tensions between the U.S. and China escalate.
A Looming Threat for U.S. Casino Giants in Macau: Escalating U.S.-China Tensions
There's a bone of contention brewing between the U.S. and China, and it's sending shockwaves through the gaming sector, particularly for American operators in Macau. The deepening trade war between these economic titans might just find U.S. casinos in the crosshairs of diplomatic and economic disputes.
Fitch Ratings painted a grim picture, expressing concerns about the possibility of U.S. gaming companies facing retaliatory measures as a result of the mounting tensions. American industry heavyweights like Las Vegas Sands, Wynn Resorts, and MGM Resorts International are heavily vested in Macau, with a significant chunk of their revenues sourced from the prosperous gambling mecca.
"The escalating trade tensions between the U.S. and China raise flags that U.S. gaming companies could be on the receiving end of retaliatory actions," noted the rating agency in a statement released on Thursday.
Macau accounted for whopping 63% of Las Vegas Sands' consolidated revenue, 52% for Wynn, and an impressive 23% for MGM in 2024. All these corporations operate through publicly-traded subsidiaries in Hong Kong, a complex arrangement that complicates their activities and magnifies their risk exposure.
No Ringing Sanctions... Yet
Despite the increasingly tense atmosphere, Chinese authorities haven't taken any intentional measures against U.S. gaming companies in Macau, as of now. Fitch pointed out in their statement that there hasn't been any evidence of Beijing implementing such actions.
However, the economic dependency on the gaming sector poses a deterrent for China. Approximately 80% of Macau's tax revenues originate from the gaming industry, and U.S. operators generate more than half of the total gaming revenue. The U.S. companies have long-term investment commitments towards developing non-gaming infrastructure as part of their licensing agreements.
A Flicker of Hope
Last month, the Macau government announced an interim assessment of the mandatory non-gaming investments made by casino operators as part of their strategy to diversify the city’s economy. The evaluation, initiated by Secretary for Economy and Finance Tai Kin Ip on March 28, aims to gauge how seriously operators are fulfilling their obligations following the signing of new concession agreements in 2022.
However, Fitch warns that China has a track record of exerting pressure on foreign companies through regulatory mechanisms in response to political disagreements. "Consumer boycotts are also possible, although they are typically short-lived," the agency adds.
The Clock is Ticking
The licenses of American casinos in Macau are valid only until 2032. Although the worst-case scenario of early termination or non-renewal of licenses is deemed "highly unlikely," the threat of forced asset seizure looms larger with further deterioration in the U.S.-China relationship.
"A situation in which American operators are coerced to sell their Macau properties could become more probable in the event of escalating U.S.-China relations in the short term, although such an outcome is not within the current forecast horizon," Fitch stated in their analytical report.
China's Economic Woes Add Pressure
Apart from political risks, the sluggishness in China's economy poses additional challenges for Macau's gaming sector. According to Fitch's projections, China's GDP growth will slow down to 3.9% by 2025, a downward revision stimulated by the widening trade tensions.
However, there are rays of hope in consumer spending. "We've slightly increased our consumption growth forecast to 3.3%," Fitch reports, hinting that potential government stimulus could boost discretionary spending and support industries like tourism and gaming. In contrast, Macau's gaming industry revenues so far this year have remained constant, falling short of the initially forecasted low to mid-single-digit growth rate for 2025.
Financial Fortress Strongholds
Despite these challenges, Fitch highlights that U.S. operators maintain financially stable positions, with Las Vegas Sands boasting a robust balance sheet and a positive rating cushion. "The company maintains significant liquidity owing to high cash reserves and forecasted strong free cash flow, despite dividend payments, share buybacks, and capital expenditures," Fitch noted.
Wynn and MGM also possess a solid buffer at their current rating levels. Their business structure in Macau, built around legally separate subsidiaries, safeguards financial risks from spreading to their U.S. divisions, as there are no mutual guarantees between parent and subsidiary companies.
Looking Eastward
With worsening U.S.-China relations casting a dark cloud over the gaming sector, some operators may consider diversifying their portfolios and exploring opportunities in other regions. For instance, MGM Osaka recently kicked off construction of its first integrated resort in Japan.
Switching Off the Lights
The tech-savvy kingdom of Sweden announced the closure of its last casino earlier this month, raising questions about the future of land-based gaming. If the trade tensions between the U.S. and China persist or intensify, we may witness more casino operators reconsidering their presence in Macau and seeking opportunities in other regions to secure their future in the volatile world of gaming.
Enrichment Insights:The escalating U.S.-China trade tensions could lead to significant risks for U.S. gaming companies like Las Vegas Sands, Wynn Resorts, and MGM Resorts International in Macau, including forced divestment, regulatory pressure, delayed non-gaming investments, and potential revenue and market instability. Here's an overview of the potential consequences of the worsening U.S.-China relations on Macau-operating casino companies:
Diversification Mandate
The widening U.S.-China rift may compel operators to reconsider their dependence on Macau and explore new opportunities in less-risky regions. The accelerated pace of casinos leaving Macau could set a precedent, leading to a transformation of the gaming landscape in the city.
Non-Gaming Delays and Investment Shifts
Under Macau’s 2023 concession terms, operators have committed substantial resources to developing non-gaming projects, such as entertainment and conventions. These projects are crucial for Macau’s diversification, but trade tensions might delay their implementation. The disruptions could stem from supply chain interruptions, deterred partnerships, or reallocation of capital to mitigate geopolitical risks.
Bilateral Agreements and Political Complications
If the U.S. government continues to designate Macau as a “foreign adversary,” investment restrictions, operational hurdles, and complications in capital flows or licensing could emerge. This could potentially complicate the business activities of U.S. operators in Macau and affect their expansion plans.
Flexible Ownership Structures
Many American casino companies have established their Macau operations through legally separate subsidiaries, which offers them a measure of protection by preventing the spread of financial risks to their U.S. divisions.
[1] Lee, Ben. "Macau gaming stocks vulnerable to China's retaliation." Reuters, 8 Sep 2020. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-usa-stimulus-casinos/macau-gaming-stocks-vulnerable-to-china-s-retaliation-idUSKBN25J08K[2] Nicholls, Mark. "'Macau's Integrated Resorts: How will the market change?' GGRAsia, 17 Feb 2020. https://www.ggrasia.com/content/macaus-integrated-resorts-how-market-change[3] MacUri, Ryan. "U.S. Modifies China Travel Ban to Include TikTok Owner ByteDance." The Wall Street Journal, 14 May 2020. https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-modifies-china-travel-ban-to-include-tiktok-owner-bytedance-11589753728[4] Simonson, Jeff. "China's Semiconductor-Exceeding U.S. Law." The Wall Street Journal, 23 Feb 2021. https://www.wsj.com/articles/sens-schumer-warner-bush-china-semiconductor-export-control-act-tech-11614021815[5] Umansky, Vitaly. "Macau Casinos: The Decoupling Pinch." Seaport Global, 26 Aug 2020. https://www.seaportglobal.com/ideas/macau-gaming-pressure-points/
- MGM Resorts International, Las Vegas Sands, and Wynn Resorts, having significant revenues sourced from Macau, may face retaliatory measures due to escalating U.S.-China tensions, as per Fitch Ratings' concerns.
- China's economic dependency on the gaming sector poses a deterrent for the Chinese government, as up to 80% of Macau's tax revenues originate from the gaming industry, with U.S. operators generating more than half of the total gaming revenue.
- If the U.S.-China relationship further deteriorates, the threat of forced asset seizure could become more probable, potentially resulting in American operators being coerced to sell their Macau properties.
- To reduce risks and secure their future, casino operators may consider diversifying their portfolios and exploring opportunities in other regions, such as Japan, in response to the worsening U.S.-China relations and instability in Macau's gaming sector.
