Title: Is Germany Overlooking Cost Savings in its Budgeting Strategy?
In the quest to complete the 2024 federal budget, Germany had to round up an additional 17 billion euros. This subsequent burden will be shouldered by consumers, leading to increased expenses for essentials such as heating, refueling, and dining out. A recent disclosure from the Federal Ministry of Finance, however, reveals that alternative funding options were overlooked.
Christian Görke, a member of the Left Party, questioned the Ministry about the potential savings that could have been achieved if the federal government had spread its interest expenses over several years. This proposed strategy could have reduced the interest expenses estimated at 36.83 billion euros in 2023 to a more manageable 19.84 billion euros, a difference of 16.99 billion euros. Despite the apparent correlation between this figure and the missing 17 billion euros, some say this shift in strategy might alleviate the perception of the state financing its own poverty.
The federal government has traditionally budgeted its interest expenses in full at once. This practice is peculiar, with critics suggesting it's more a habit than best financial practice. Chancellor Olaf Scholz also followed suit during his tenure as Federal Minister of Finance. It's worth noting that many industrialized nations distribute the interest costs over the bond's term, a strategy that smoothens budget fluctuations and presents a clearer financial situation.
Bonds serve as crucial financing tools for governments like Germany. When the federal government takes on new debt via bonds, it pays interest on these debts. Federal bonds are typically traded on the stock exchange, and investors buy these bonds in exchange for annual interest payments until the bond's maturity. Regardless of the bond price fluctuations, the government must buy back the bond at its nominal value before the end of the term.
Interest expenses can also impact bond prices. In periods of low market interest rates, bond prices may exceed their nominal value, leading to premiums. These premiums are then deducted from the interest paid to the investors, lowering the overall interest expenses in the budget.
However, the German federal government has been criticized for not distributing these accrued premiums over the bond's term. Instead, the entire sum is claimed in the year the bond is issued. In 2021, the German Bundesbank recommended distributing interest on an accrual basis, stating that this approach would provide a more stable budget situation, easier budgetary planning, and a better-complied debt brake.
Economists are divided on the topic; some see it as a break from established accounting logic, while others believe that periodic accounting is economically appropriate, provided it's implemented consistently. Critics argue that implementing such change now might give the impression that the budget is in crisis and the government needs to find alternative funding sources.
The extent of potential savings through this accounting change remains unclear, and it's theoretically possible for budget projections to paint a misleading picture if interest rates fluctuate significantly. This misrepresentation can potentially alter budgetary planning and the compliance with debt limits.
Sources:
