Breakdown of Top NFL Rookies to Keep an Eye On in 2025

Breakdown of Top NFL Rookies to Keep an Eye On in 2025

Top 10 Rookies to Watch in the 2025 NFL Season

As the NFL Draft 2025 comes to a close, excitement is building for the upcoming season, with several promising rookies set to make their mark. Here's a detailed overview of the top 10 rookies to keep an eye on, focusing on their potential performance, strengths, weaknesses, and rookie year expectations:

1. Marvin Harrison Jr. (WR, Arizona Cardinals)
2. Strengths: Elite collegiate production at Ohio State, physical talent, size, and continuity in offense with the same quarterback in 2025.
3. Weaknesses: Disappointing rookie season with 62 catches, 885 yards, and 8 touchdowns. Competition for targets with Trey McBride remains.
4. Expectations: Seen as a potential breakout candidate if the Cardinals optimize his usage; needs to finish top 9 among WRs to justify fantasy value. Likely undervalued after rookie year, offering upside despite a slow start.
5. Tetairoa McMillan (WR, Carolina Panthers)
6. Strengths: Large frame (6'4", 220 lbs) with good speed (4.5 40-yard dash), highly productive college career, All-American status, and expected to get early targets from QB Bryce Young.
7. Weaknesses: Transition to NFL level and Panthers' overall offensive consistency are factors to monitor.
8. Expectations: Projected to make an immediate impact as one of the best receivers in his class, likely to be a top rookie WR in usage and production.
9. Walter Nolen III (DT, Arizona Cardinals)
10. Strengths: Expected to play 55% of defensive snaps, especially in run-heavy sets, and upside as a developing pass rusher.
11. Weaknesses: Currently a rotational role behind veterans, and consistency still in development.
12. Expectations: Could carve out a meaningful role on a Cardinals defensive line that mixes youth with experience; potential for an increased role if pass rush skills improve.
13. Will Johnson (CB, Arizona Cardinals)
14. Strengths: Projected to play near full defensive snaps (900-1,000), indicating immediate starting cornerback role.
15. Weaknesses: None highlighted explicitly; rookie CBs often challenge adjusting to NFL speed and route complexity.
16. Expectations: High immediate impact in the secondary, valuable for defensive schemes requiring CB depth.
17. Cody Simon (LB, Arizona Cardinals)
18. Strengths: Expected to play significant snaps (500-700); a likely contributor in linebacker rotation.
19. Weakies: Changing role and competition for snaps.
20. Expectations: Potential key role player on defense with opportunity to prove reliability and grow.
21. Jayden Higgins (WR, Houston Texans)
22. Strengths: Second-round pick, big-bodied receiver with ability to fill gap left by Tank Dell's injury, and complementary receiver to Nico Collins and Christian Kirk.
23. Weaknesses: Needs to establish chemistry with QB and adjust to NFL pace.
24. Expectations: Could be a key breakout rookie receiver for Houston; X-factor in Texans’ passing offense.
25. Caleb Williams (QB, Chicago Bears) [Second Year]
26. Strengths: Exceptional passing ability from college, Bears have upgraded coaching and offensive line, and improved pass catchers.
27. Weaknesses: Sacked heavily in rookie year (68 sacks), indicating prior poor line protection, and Bears’ overall playoff chances not favored.
28. Expectations: Poised for a significant leap in performance, possibly achieving 4,000+ passing yards and 30+ touchdowns in 2025.
29. Shemar Stewart (DL, Cincinnati Bengals)
30. Strengths: First-round talent; potential impact part of defensive upgrade.
31. Weaknesses: Contract issues caused struggles, defensive improvement uncertain due to personnel turnover and coordinator change.
32. Expectations: Needs to settle contract and adapt to new defensive scheme; could be a key part of defense if he develops.
33. Other Notable Rookies Mentioned
34. Jacory Croskey-Merritt
35. Jaydon Blue
36. Tahj Brooks
37. Jarquez Hunter
38. Jaylin Noel

These players are highlighted for potential fantasy impacts or situational contributions but with less expectation for immediate stardom.

Summary of Strengths vs. Expectations:

| Player | Position | Strengths | Rookie Impact Expectation | Weaknesses/Concerns | |---------------------|----------|--------------------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------------------------| | Marvin Harrison Jr. | WR | Elite college production, size, familiarity | Potential breakout with better usage | Slow rookie season, competition for targets | | Tetairoa McMillan | WR | Size, speed, college productivity | Expected significant immediate role | Transition uncertainties | | Walter Nolen III | DT | Strong run defense, rotational pass-rush potential | Plays 50-55% snaps in rotation | Developing pass rush consistency | | Will Johnson | CB | High snap count projection | Immediate starter | NFL speed adjustments | | Cody Simon | LB | Significant snap projection | Rotation contributor | Role competition | | Jayden Higgins | WR | Size, opportunity with Texans | Potential key pass catcher | Needs to build chemistry | | Caleb Williams | QB | Elite passer, improved supporting cast | Big sophomore leap in passing stats | Past protection issues | | Shemar Stewart | DL | First-round talent | Potential defensive impact with resolved contracts | Contract stability, scheme adjustment |

Overall, expectations for the 2025 rookie class include a mix of immediate contributors on both sides of the ball and several with breakout potential if given proper opportunities and development. Wide receivers like Marvin Harrison Jr., Tetairoa McMillan, and Jayden Higgins are among the most intriguing offensive rookies. Defensive rookies like Walter Nolen III and Will Johnson also figure to earn meaningful playing time. Quarterback Caleb Williams, as a second-year player, is poised for a major performance jump.

The rookie classes are also influenced by team situations, coaching, offensive line quality, and supporting talent, which will impact their ultimate performance levels in their rookie campaigns. Stay tuned for updates on these exciting rookies as they make their mark in the 2025 NFL season.

[1] [Source 1] [2] [Source 2] [3] [Source 3] [4] [Source 4] [5] [Source 5]

1. The upcoming 2025 NFL season promises to showcase the skills of American-football rookies such as Marvin Harrison Jr., Tetairoa McMillan, and Jayden Higgins, as they are highlighted among the most intriguing offensive rookies.
2. Additionally, football fans should keep an eye on Walter Nolen III and Will Johnson, both defensive rookies who are expected to earn meaningful playing time and potentially make an impact in their respective positions.

Read also: