Backpacking Tent Comparison: Freestanding vs. Non-Freestanding Models
Updated Article:
When it comes to backpacking tents, you'll notice they're often categorized as "freestanding" or "non-freestanding." But what exactly does that mean, and which style is best for your needs? Here's a breakdown of these two setups, outlining their primary differences and helping you make an informed decision.
We've pitched tents in all sorts of places - from the wilds of Patagonia to Utah's sandstone canyons, and the Pacific Northwest's lush forests. If you're hungry for more recommendations, check out our guides on the top backpacking tents, ultralight tents, and budget backpacking tents.
Types of Backpacking Tents
Freestanding
Freestanding tents are self-supporting, meaning they maintain their shape without needing to be staked out. These tents are supported by poles, allowing you to pick them up and move them around camp without them drooping. Many freestanding tents, such as the popular Big Agnes Copper Spur HV UL2, feature separate rainflies, but some designs boast single-wall waterproof constructions. Freestanding tents are favored by many campers and traditional backpackers due to their ease of setup, impressive weather protection, and superior comfort and living space.
While freestanding tents don't require staking to retain their shape, it's still beneficial to stake them out taut to maximize floor area and improve protection from wind and rain. Generally, rainflies must also be staked to create vestibule space for your gear and effectively shed moisture.
Non-Freestanding
Unlike freestanding models, non-freestanding tents require staking to hold their shape. To set up, non-freestanding tents are staked out first and often then propped up with trekking poles (or use a single tent pole). These tents are typically single-wall designs that prioritize low weight and pack size over comfort, convenience, and livable space. As a result, non-freestanding tents are favored by experienced backcountry adventurers and ultralight enthusiasts.
Semi-Freestanding
Not as common as their freestanding and non-freestanding counterparts, semi-freestanding tents combine elements from both styles. These hybrids, such as the Big Agnes Tiger Wall UL2, can stand on their own with the assistance of tent poles, but part of their structure still needs to be staked out. Semi-freestanding tents can be a practical compromise, offering a balance between the headroom and weather protection of freestanding tents and the low weight and smaller packed size of non-freestanding shelters.
Performance Differences
Weather Protection: Freestanding > Non-Freestanding
Freestanding tents offer superior weather protection due to their dedicated pole structures, which are slightly stronger in windy conditions, and their double-wall design (many non-freestanding models are single-wall). Because double-wall designs have an extra layer of separation from the elements, they provide enhanced protection from rain and wind. The Rain Jacket analogy works here: Double-wall tents give you one additional layer between you and the elements, while single-wall tents leave you exposed.
Ventilation: Freestanding > Non-Freestanding
Double-wall designs, common in freestanding tents, offer superior ventilation thanks to their breathable inner tent bodies, allowing condensation to escape. Single-wall tents struggle to meet both breathability and waterproof demands simultaneously; this is especially true in lightweight Dyneema designs like the Zpacks Duplex Zip. To boost ventilation in your single-wall tent, orient it to allow wind flow through open vestibule doors (when it's not raining), or choose a model with small integrated vents.
Weight and Packed Size: Non-Freestanding > Freestanding
Lightweight and compactness are where non-freestanding tents truly shine. Minimalist single-wall designs, often lacking trekking poles and extra fabric, fare significantly better in terms of weight and pack size compared to freestanding counterparts. Freestanding tents are rapidly catching up - consider the 1-pound-15.6-ounce Zpacks Free Zip 2P - but you'll likely sacrifice durability and pay a premium for these designs catering to ultralight enthusiasts.
Interior Space: Freestanding > Non-Freestanding
Freestanding tents provide better livability, boasting steeper walls and greater headroom. Non-freestanding tents, however, often have a cramped, A-frame shape. When stuck in a prolonged storm, we'd much rather spend the time inside a spacious freestanding tent like the REI Co-op Half Dome SL 2. For larger groups or more comfort, freestanding tents are usually spacious enough for four people, while non-freestanding shelters tend to accommodate three.
Durability: Tie
Both freestanding and non-freestanding tents exhibit similar durability, depending on material quality and construction. This becomes more pertinent when discussing ultralight options, where many manufacturers reduce fabric thickness to save weight, requiring extra care when setting up and handling your tent. If you want an ultralight tent without sacrificing durability, a non-freestanding tent is more likely to last.
Vestibule Area: Tie
Both freestanding and non-freestanding tents can be equipped with vestibules, making it difficult to determine an overall winner. Vestibule sizes range widely, so it's essential to evaluate each tent's specifications, as listed as "vestibule area" in square feet or meters.
Setup: Tie
Freestanding tents can be set up almost anywhere, making them easy to relocate if needed. This advantage comes with the drawback of a learning curve when setting up in difficult terrain. Non-freestanding tents, on the other hand, must be staked out at your chosen site but can be set up in the rain without risking wetting the inner tent, as there's no need to erect the body before attaching the fly.
Versatility: Freestanding > Non-Freestanding
Double-wall freestanding tents offer greater versatility, allowing you to use the rainfly as a shield or remove it for better airflow or a panoramic view, depending on weather conditions. Fine-tuning your tent to suit specific environments is easier with double-wall designs. Non-freestanding tents, for the most part, have just one configuration.
Price: Tie
The market offers both affordable and expensive options in both freestanding and non-freestanding tent categories. Generally, lighter tents (both freestanding and non-freestanding) are more expensive due to the cost of lightweight materials and the quality of construction required for durability. For more budget-friendly options, check out our guide on the best budget backpacking tents.
Our Favorite Tents
We hope this information helps you make a smarter decision when choosing your next backpacking tent. If you need further assistance, take a closer look at our top picks in both the freestanding and non-freestanding categories:
Best Overall Freestanding: Big Agnes Copper Spur HV UL2Best Budget Freestanding: REI Co-op Trail Hut 2Best Ultralight Freestanding: Nemo Hornet Elite Osmo 2P
Best Overall Non-Freestanding: Tarptent Double RainbowBest Budget Non-Freestanding: Durston X-Mid 2Best Ultralight Non-Freestanding: Zpacks Duplex Zip
For even more recommendations and detailed advice on selecting the right backpacking tent for your adventures, see our comprehensive guides on the best backpacking tents, best ultralight tents, and best budget backpacking tents. Happy exploring!
During your outdoor expeditions, it's essential to consider the suitability of travel gear such as backpacking tents. While backpacking, freestanding tents, like the Big Agnes Copper Spur HV UL2, offer superior living space and weather protection, making them popular choices for campers. On the other hand, sports enthusiasts who prefer ultralight equipment might gravitate towards non-freestanding tents, such as the Zpacks Duplex Zip, due to their lighter weight and compactness. Whether embarking on a trail or venturing into the backcountry, the right backpacking tent enhances your sports experience, providing a comfortable shelter for travel and adventure.
