Bachelor contestant posts disrespectful remark about Katie Thurston and her spouse, prompting a response from the "Bachelorette" star
In a surprising turn of events, former Bachelorette contestant Cody Menk has found himself at the centre of controversy after making a classless comment on Katie Thurston's wedding picture.
The comment, which was shared under an Instagram picture of Katie and her husband Jeff Arcuri on their wedding day, was met with a wave of negative reactions from fans. Some called it terrible, trash, and classless, while others speculated that it was motivated by jealousy.
According to reports, Menk wrote "Good couple! Both solid 5s," along with a laughing emoji on the picture. This comment, which was perceived as insensitive and disrespectful, was not well-received by many fans.
One fan expressed their disapproval by saying, "Why would he think this was okay. What an idiot!" Another Reddit user added, "He's lucky to have even breathed in her direction wtf. Absolutely classless."
Katie Thurston, who appeared on Season 17 of The Bachelorette, posted a screenshot of Menk's comment on her Instagram Stories and expressed her disapproval. She moved up her wedding to Jeff Arcuri due to her diagnosis with stage 4 breast cancer[1], and the wedding was attended by many fans.
Despite the backlash, Menk has not publicly responded to the criticism just yet. He has since removed his comment from Katie Thurston's wedding picture, but his initial actions have left a lasting impression on fans.
It's worth noting that Menk was eliminated from Katie Thurston's season of The Bachelorette two weeks into the series due to concerns about his intentions. He is a sales manager by profession.
This latest incident serves as a reminder that actions have consequences, and it's important to treat others with respect and kindness, especially on such a joyous occasion as a wedding.
[1] Parade, "Katie Thurston's Wedding: Inside the Bachelorette Star's Romantic Ceremony with Jeff Arcuri," accessed August 7, 2025, https://parade.com/1033002/maria-vultaggio/katie-thurston-wedding-inside-the-bachelorette-stars-romantic-ceremony-with-jeff-arcuri/
- Critics might argue that Cody Menk's timely television appearance on 'The Bachelorette' has partially contributed to his notoriety, as his classless comment about Katie Thurston's wedding picture has generated even more controversy.
- The recent pop-culture debate centers around celebrities like Menk, who find themselves at the center of discussions about entertainment etiquette, with fans questioning the appropriateness of his comment on Katie Thurston's wedding photo.
- Following Katie Thurston's joyous wedding, which was graced by thousands of television show fans, a shocking oversight by former contestant Cody Menk has led to a significant blow to his reputation in the realm of pop-culture.
