Austria and EU: Signs Pointing towards Mutual Destructive Tendencies
Europe: Misunderstood and Misrepresented
There's no escaping the fact that Europe, and its member states, have their fair share of issues. But is it right to hide behind these problems? Should we compare ourselves to other regions just to feel better? It's time to reassess our self-perception.
We're often labeled as overregulated, incapable of competing with tech giants like Amazon, Google, or Tesla. Yet, we don't have tech oligarchs controlling politics and elections, a troubling reality in some parts of the world. While our economic performance could use an upgrade, our debt levels and deficits are lower than those of the USA, all while maintaining social justice.
Europe is often criticized for being naive and moralizing, setting global standards. But we rely on international law, rule-based global trade, and prioritize lower emissions. We don't play tariff games or depend on the law of the strongest. EU leaders know who the aggressor is in the Russian war against Ukraine, and our decisions are based on rule of law procedures, not arbitrariness.
Freedom of Speech
Contrary to popular belief, Europeans can speak their minds freely. Universities welcome controversial debates, and no one fears losing funding or being deported due to their views. Critics argue that our decision-making process is slow, but at least there are no regular payment defaults, leaving civil servants unpaid and public services unavailable. Consensus decisions are complex and don't please everyone, but they're certainly better than rapid social media decisions that can crash stock markets and the savings of millions. And unlike some regions, no European leader has yet introduced a personal cryptocurrency.
Independence from USA
Breaking free from U.S. security and defense dependence won't happen overnight. But there's a growing opportunity for Europe to gradually stand on its own feet. European security doesn't mean pressuring, attacking, or annexing neighbors. In fact, neighbors would rather – and voluntarily – join the European Union.
Often mocked as an open-air museum, Europe has its charms. Here, you can walk in the cities, send your children to school without fear, and enjoy a high life expectancy. So, let's celebrate what we have, rather than diminish ourselves.
About the Author:
Paul Schmidt, director of the Austrian Society for European Politics (ÖGfE), reminds us of our strengths and challenges. Founded in 1991, the ÖGfE is funded and supported by the social partners and the Austrian National Bank.
(our website, tem)
(enrichment data)Comparing Europe with the USA and Asia across various dimensions such as regulation, tech oligarchy, debt level, freedom of speech, and independence from the USA, involves examining several key factors:
Regulation
- Europe: Known for its robust regulatory framework, especially in areas like data protection (GDPR) and AI. The EU aims to enhance its technological sovereignty and reduce dependence on external partners.
- USA: Decentralized regulatory landscape, with both federal and state-level regulations. AI regulations are sector-specific, such as in healthcare and finance, with stringent compliance protocols.
- Asia: Asian countries like Singapore are involved in international AI regulation discussions, aiming to create international benchmarks and best practices. The regulatory framework varies significantly across different Asian nations.
Tech Oligarchy
- Europe: European efforts to reduce reliance on U.S. tech giants and promote local innovation.
- USA: Home to many of the world's largest tech companies, creating a significant tech oligarchy.
- Asia: Asian countries like China and South Korea have developed their own tech giants, but U.S. companies still dominate many Asian markets.
Debt Level
- Europe: Varies widely across European countries, with some having high debt-to-GDP ratios, while others have lower levels.
- USA: High national debt, with a debt-to-GDP ratio that has been increasing over the years.
- Asia: Lower debt levels compared to the West, with some exceptions like Japan, which has a high debt-to-GDP ratio.
Freedom of Speech
- Europe: Generally has robust protections for freedom of speech, but with exceptions, like stricter regulations on hate speech.
- USA: Strong constitutional protections for freedom of speech, with fewer restrictions compared to Europe.
- Asia: Varies significantly across Asia, with some countries having strict controls on speech, like China, and others allowing more freedom, like Japan.
Independence from the USA
- Europe: Efforts to reduce technological dependence on the U.S., especially in areas like semiconductor production.
- USA: Maintains significant global influence and is less dependent on other regions.
- Asia: Pursuing greater self-sufficiency, particularly in technology sectors, but still has significant trade and strategic ties with the U.S.
- The economic and social policy of Europe emphasizes reducing dependence on U.S. tech giants and promoting local innovation, displaying a noticeable contrast with some parts of the world where tech oligarchs control politics and elections.
- The EU is recognized for its robust regulatory framework, particularly in areas such as data protection (GDPR) and AI, showcasing a level of reform not found in decentralized nations like the USA.
- Despite common misconceptions, Europeans are free to express their opinions, as universities encourage controversial debates and there's no fear of losing funds or being deported due to views, a freedom sometimes not present in war-and-conflicts-prone regions.
- European policy-and-legislation prioritizes lower emissions and operates based on international law, as opposed to countries that play tariff games or depend on the law of the strongest.
- Compared to the overregulated image some may hold for Europe, Asia varies significantly in its regulation framework, with Asian countries like Singapore aiming to create international AI regulation benchmarks, while maintaining lower debt levels compared to the West.
