Skip to content

Archbishop of Canterbury steps down amidst controversy over mishandled abuse allegations

"The Anglican leader admits the need for personal and institutional accountability regarding the distressing and prolonged period from 2013 to 2024."

Archbishop of Canterbury steps down amidst controversy over concealed mistreatment allegations
Archbishop of Canterbury steps down amidst controversy over concealed mistreatment allegations

Archbishop of Canterbury steps down amidst controversy over mishandled abuse allegations

Justin Welby, the Archbishop of Canterbury, announced his resignation on Tuesday, following revelations of an abuse cover-up scandal involving a former mentor, John Smyth. The process for selecting Welby's successor has begun, with several key steps and considerations involved.

## Selection Process

The Crown Nominations Commission (CNC) is responsible for finding the next Archbishop. The commission has emphasised the need to approach the search with an open mind, indicating a discernment process rather than a selection based on preconceived notions.

The job description for the next Archbishop includes being someone of the "utmost integrity" and potentially a woman. The role requires strong spiritual leadership skills to navigate the complexities of the Church of England and the Anglican Communion.

Historical and theological considerations are also crucial. The next Archbishop must balance the historical teachings of Anglicanism with modern societal changes. Some emphasise the need to uphold traditional values and biblical orthodoxy, while others advocate for affirming pro-LGBTQ directions while maintaining historic teachings on marriage.

## Key Challenges

The next Archbishop will face significant challenges, particularly in managing the global Anglican Communion, which is now predominantly in the Global South and often holds to traditional values. Balancing these perspectives with those in the Western world will be essential.

Calls for an Archbishop who can affirm both traditional teachings and modern inclusivity, such as pro-LGBTQ stances, highlight the need for balance and unity within the Church.

## Timeline

The exact timeline for the appointment is not specified, but the process involves consultations with various stakeholders and a final recommendation by the CNC to the prime minister, who then forwards it to the monarch for approval. The process is likely to be lengthy, given the complexity of the role and the need for consensus among different groups within the Church.

Justin Welby has stated that he will honour his Constitutional and church responsibilities, and exact timings for his resignation will be decided once a review of necessary obligations has been completed. The process of choosing Welby's successor is likely to take at least six months.

## The Abuse Scandal

Before becoming an Archbishop, Justin Welby worked as a dormitory supervisor of the camps run by John Smyth in Dorset. Smyth is accused of subjecting over 100 boys and young men to "traumatic physical, sexual, psychological, and spiritual" abuse over 40 years.

The Makin Report, an independent review into the handling of allegations against Smyth, found that Justin Welby "could and should" have reported Smyth's abuse of boys and young men in 2013. Welby admitted that the Makin Review exposed the long-maintained conspiracy of silence about Smyth's abuses.

Welby stated that he will "follow through on my commitment to meet victims" before delegating his responsibilities. It is most probable that Welby would have had at least a level of knowledge that Smyth was of some concern.

The Archbishop of York, Stephen Cottrell, described Welby's resignation as "the right and honourable decision". The Archbishop of Canterbury, Justin Welby, is stepping down due to the abuse cover-up scandal.

Sources: [1] The Guardian [2] BBC News [3] Church Times [4] Christian Today [5] Evangelical Focus - europe - The Archbishop of Canterbury resigns amid abuse cover-up scandal.

The upcoming selection process for the next Archbishop of Canterbury, following Justin Welby's resignation, will involve a balanced approach, considering the Role's requirements of strong spiritual leadership, 'utmost integrity', and potential female candidates. The new Archbishop will also need to navigate complex politics within the Church of England, the Anglican Communion, and the general-news landscape, while addressing crime-and-justice concerns arising from the handling of the John Smyth abuse scandal.

Read also:

    Latest