A look at eras marked by turbulence and upheaval
=======================================================================================
India Donaldson's directorial debut, "Good One," has been warmly received by critics and audiences alike. The film, which premiered at the 2024 Sundance Film Festival, stars Lily Collins as 17-year-old Sam, James Le Gros as Chris, and Danny McCarthy as Matt.
The story unfolds over three days in the Catskill Mountains, where a near-family outing in nature transforms into a poignant tale of growing up and disappointment. The film features hiking, spartan camping life, campfires, and small talk, all captured beautifully by cinematographer Wilson Cameron.
Sam's maturity and resilience are evident, suggesting she will manage despite her challenges. The burden she carries alone grows heavier with each passing hour, symbolized as an uncomfortable backpack filled with seemingly light but collectively substantial trinkets.
Lily Collins's performance as Sam, particularly as a queer 17-year-old daughter, has been lauded as extraordinary for a first role. Sam strives to show attention and empathy towards her father, humorously enduring his pedantic ways, compromising, and tactfully diffusing tension.
Matt and Dylan's mutual resentment from their recent divorce is still raw and painful in the film. When Sam needs support and protection, her father, whom she turns to, lets her down, admitting his own unreliability. Sam offers Matt mature and sensible advice on improving his relationship with his son, drawing from her own experience as a child of divorce.
Both Chris and Matt are experiencing midlife crises, exhibiting immature behavior. Sam, intelligent and perceptive, witnesses their complaints about life, work, and ex-wives, and attempts to justify past mistakes, shifting blame, boastful self-deception, and self-pity.
The director does not rush Sam to make decisions. Instead, Donaldson portrays Sam's despair and pain simply and quietly, without force or exaggeration. Sam is allowed to remain a child a little longer, taking a pause before stepping into adulthood, where she'll have to rely solely on herself.
The film has been compared to works by Kelly Reichardt for its atmospheric and vibe-driven storytelling. Reviewers describe it as a "quiet yet powerful indie film" that captures generational differences with subtlety and tenderness.
However, there is some division among audiences, with some considering the film slow or "artistic fluff," indicating that its understated style may not appeal to everyone. Still, overall critical reception seems to be favorable, emphasizing the film’s intimate, thoughtful storytelling and strong performances.
As of now, "Good One" has not garnered major industry awards. Julian Grey plays Matt's son Dylan in the film. The film's beautiful cinematography, sound design, and naturalistic dialogue have been appreciated by all.
In conclusion, "Good One" is a sensitive and assured coming-of-age tale that offers a realistic depiction of family dynamics and nature settings. It is a must-watch for those who appreciate subtle storytelling and strong performances.
The engaging narrative of "Good One" falls under the broad spectrum of movies-and-tv entertainment, showcasing the profound struggles of a family in a serene Catskill Mountain setting. This work of entertainment also features exceptional performances from Lily Collins, earning her acclaim for her portrayal of a queer 17-year-old.
